You must Sign In to post a response.
  • Category: General

    Old books to continue -Right or wrong?

    The new govt has decided to stop the samachir kalvi books and continue the old books this year also .What is the reason behind this? Is the reason told is right or wrong? The media says that all the books has the poem of kalaignar written for semmozhi manadu and his life history is given in Tamil books.So ego of the CM is the reason behind this move.But I see more.It is the move to encourage the demand of private schools.That is give freedom to follow the books they wish.Thus to bring back the positive move kalaignar brought in education.
  • #4126
    This is sample. We can expect a lot more from our beloved CM.
    Priyamudan,
    Suresh Kumar R.
    Engal Vazhvum Engal Valamum Mangaadha Tamizh Endru Sangae Muzhanku

  • #4127
    hai friends.,

    This is really wrong.many of the people and many school student will suffer this decision.

    I don't know why CM do this.Arise Question to CM.

    Guys do u have any E-Mail id to post the question to the CM.

    Regards
    Maiyappan @ Tamil
    Enjoy Every Second In Life

  • #4136
    Hi friends

    Whats wrong in it? Put yourself in that place and see the scene coming in front of you, how do you feel happy like Ravana laughing loud in Ramayana, its all in the game folks.

    Remember when you were angry withsome in school or college days even for that matter now, how do you feel when you defeat someone who has always been your enemy for lifetime, its the same please our new CM gets in doing this, I know its getting personal so what there is no other option , its all fair in politics and sports is the new saying!

    Regards
    Kiran

  • #4139
    Hi friends,

    samachir kalvi is a good education method. But our CM changed this why this happens? I will not agree with kiran kumar.. what are you trying to say? is politics games and our Tamil Nadu is playground. Not like that CM Should work for us. Whatever matter behind this decision of our CM, this will not affect our children studies. Either Samchir kalvi nor Current system will not affect our children. but this decision of our CM, made people to think that "CM Starts her war".

    Regards,
    Vathsala R.

  • #4141
    Hi Vathsala

    Irrespective of whether we like it or not, things will happen this way as politics is being used by them to play their games of revenge and to show their power, we can do nothing than be an audience to watch them perform their best!

    Regards
    Kiran

  • #4147
    Hi Kiran, Your reply is really a shock. She is elected by the people of TN and she should serve for them and its her duty. if she has any personal things with DMK & Karunanidhi then she should deal with them directly. because of her action, only MK gets affected then no one is going to question it publicly.
    I think she doesn't learn anything from her past mistakes. TN people especially first time voters in the past 2011 election has much hope on her. Hope she didn't get any suitcases from private school mafias and wont disappoint the young voters.

    Priyamudan,
    Suresh Kumar R.
    Engal Vazhvum Engal Valamum Mangaadha Tamizh Endru Sangae Muzhanku

  • #4148
    Merchants of education continuously were opposing samachchir kalvi.They have influenced the Tamil nadu govt.CM has declared to continue samachchir kalavi.But the new books are below the standard.so a new ccommittee will analyse the books.our question is who has said the standard is low with which scale they found this.?It is very clear that the ego is not the reason.Her policy is not equality as she studied church park convent ooty .So it is the voice of Arjuna who cut the thumb of Eklaiva by force of govt power and Rama who killed Sambugan who studied Veda and who belonged to nonadmitted caste to study veda

  • #4152
    Hi Friends,

    Why you people are blaming her only. I don't think she took this decision because of her personal reason. She has lots of places is there to show her angry against DMK.

    So don't blame her. Government taking one decision means, defiantly some reasons should be there.

    yes, I too accept that, Samachir Kalvi is needed one for TN. But you have to look one thing, before leaving, what based they(DMK) desired this and which comity suggest these books are looking good ?.

    one more thing,Recently i heard, in that New books lots of good things (our Tamil religions culture & Grammars and lots of things are there without quality) are missing it seems.

    She take control 10 days before only. give a chance to her and lets we see.

    End of the year tell the same thing, if it all her current education system is not well means.

    So lets we see.

    Best Regards,
    Sakthivel.G

  • #4154
    As you said she took control just 10 days before only. Then how she judged that quality of books are low and which experts suggest her to go with old way? If some flaws are in the new books then it can overcome by upcoming years instead of her decision.

    For more than 20 years everyone talked (including ADMK) about Samachir Kalvi. Atlast it came true in 2010 and it was successful also. Now she destroyed everything like what she did for sethusamuthram project.

    Priyamudan,
    Suresh Kumar R.
    Engal Vazhvum Engal Valamum Mangaadha Tamizh Endru Sangae Muzhanku

  • #4157
    Vested interests bloc the implementation of samachir kalvi.Kalaignar himself had approved a minimum part of samachir kalvi by bringing a new sylabus.It is not at all samachir kalvi.Now that small improvement also is blocked by private schools who sell education and get great amount of money.So this step...

  • #4162
    Having something instead of nothing is far better.

    JJ announced that her govt wont interfere in private school education fee. Very good and people friendly government. Really I appreciate ADMK govt policies.

    Priyamudan,
    Suresh Kumar R.
    Engal Vazhvum Engal Valamum Mangaadha Tamizh Endru Sangae Muzhanku

  • #4166
    A good govt should interfere for good.Non interference means allowing looting in the name education.Free education bill had been passed in parliament and private schools are torturing our children.A mother who could not remit the fees for her child suicides herself last week in tamilnadu.The child is to join 1st std from UKG.So all should raise our voice for free edn and new books

  • #4209
    There is no doubt that Samacheer Kalvi is a must in Tamilnadu. But it also needs to be seen that it is implemented with quality contents and useful educative information in it.

    What Jayalalitha had said is that Samacheer Kalvi will not be implemented this year. she said that the quality of the material is not to the standards (which is very much true) and will be analyzed by experts before it is implemented effectively. Efficient leaders require a day to analyze things and not days.

    Karunanidhi has simply pushed it in its early stage (as was done with the new Secretariat building) to take due credit that it was implemented during his period.

    Politics at its very best now in education as well.

    Regards
    Rajesh

    Regards
    Rajesh

  • #4258
    Efficient will not do harm in a hasty manner.Yesterday govt has assured it will not scrap the books.Then why stopped.correction can be made by circulars while using it.Educationists have decided a well analysed syllabus.Who and how can say anyone it is low in standard ?It is a hasty and wrong decision.Now she could not justify.Politics should not disturb education.

  • #4270
    @Rajesh,
    How do you and JJ know about the quality of materials? Have you gonr through all the books or JJ gone through within 10 days? whether she got any input from educationalist experts about the quality? If yes, then who are all those experts? How can you say previous government didn't analyzed with experts? Previous year itself they implemented it for 1st and 6th Standard.

    Priyamudan,
    Suresh Kumar R.
    Engal Vazhvum Engal Valamum Mangaadha Tamizh Endru Sangae Muzhanku

  • #4358
    HI friend,
    My opinion is that there is some stuff in the old text books but in the Samacheer Kalvi books there is no usual standard compared to Matriculation Syllabus.For making a whole Tamil Nadu to be specialized in the field of Education the Samacheer Kalvi Books are to be made into existence with necessary standard topics to help students think and understand more.According to Einstein,"The things should be made Simple but not Simpler".The aiming of Samacheer(common) syllabus is a best thing and that is to be appreciated.


    with regards,
    S.ARUL FRANCES.

  • #4374
    Matric standard is not the parameter of education.Samachchir means that balancing the four streams namely matric,anglo indian ,state board and oriental of education systems .So it is the calculated and best syllabus acceptable to all over Tamilnadu.If it is not enough one can join in CBSE pattern .So the new books should be used immediately

  • #4387
    @ Suresh Kumar,

    Not only me, every educated person can judge the quality of the materials by going through the syllabus and materials. I have personally seen the materials and to my opinion they are not up to the standards when compared to the regular course materials.

    I would also like you to have a look at it and come to a fair judgement before criticizing it. After all, it's our children who are going to be put to test in future and it is our duty to see to that they get quality education up to the standards.

    Once again I reatriate that Samacheer Kalvi with quality standards is a must in Tamilnadu.

    Regards
    Rajesh

    Regards
    Rajesh

  • #4443
    Though you have gone through all new books and some of us have not gone through them,it would not justify the stanard of books.the question is that they are prepared by a group of educationists and they should be neglected also by educationists.The process would reveal its standard.

    standard should not be high.It should balance all tamilians .-poor and rich ;village and cities ,.upper castes and suppressed .They should come equal at least in education .For that the standard of these books are very good ,the educationists say.

  • #4449
    @Rajesh
    Do you think matriculation syllabus are good? What is the use of more syllabus without understanding? You might have solved so many problems and learned so many theories in maths during your study. Have you remember atleast half of them? Are you using it in your day to day life? Quantity of Syllabus doesn't matter.

    Priyamudan,
    Suresh Kumar R.
    Engal Vazhvum Engal Valamum Mangaadha Tamizh Endru Sangae Muzhanku

  • #4460
    Mrs YG parthasarathi is an educationist ,? no she is abig seller of education

  • #4462
    Recently Government released guide book temporarily. In 12th Tamil Guide, following contents are available

    "கலக்கிய வசனம்' என்ற தலைப்பில், "இந்த பாட்ஷா ஒரு தடவை சொன்னா நூறு தடவை சொன்ன மாதிரி' - பாட்ஷா ரஜினி.

    "அடைந்தால் மகாதேவி இல்லையேல் மரணதேவி' - பி.எஸ்.வீரப்பா.

    "இலக்கியத்தில் அறிவியல்' என்ற தலைப்பில், "இன்னிசை பாடி வரும்...' - துள்ளாத மனமும் துள்ளும் விஜய்.

    "கேட்டேன்' என்ற தலைப்பில், "சப்தம் இல்லாத தனிமை கேட்டேன்...' - அமர்க்களம் அஜித். இதில், அஜித் புகைப்படமும் உள்ளது.

    Is it standard education for JJ and her govt?

    Priyamudan,
    Suresh Kumar R.
    Engal Vazhvum Engal Valamum Mangaadha Tamizh Endru Sangae Muzhanku

  • #4465
    12 th books do not come under Samachchir kalvi . It only covers 1-10 classes.Moreover all lines should be reviewed in the context . may be wrong in some pages or lines .then they should and can be corrected instesd of thowing the whole text/books

  • #4466
    12 th books do not come under Samachchir kalvi . It only covers 1-10 classes.Moreover all lines should be reviewed in the context . may be wrong in some pages or lines .then they should and can be corrected instead of throwing the whole text/books

  • #4472
    @Vasudevan,

    These texts are not taken from Samacheer Text books. These lines have been taken from the guidelines books released by JJ govt for temporary purpose until final verdict given by Supreme Court.

    Priyamudan,
    Suresh Kumar R.
    Engal Vazhvum Engal Valamum Mangaadha Tamizh Endru Sangae Muzhanku

  • #4504
    we cant say samachir kalvi books released have quality content or not. Makin samachir kalvi is a good move. Chief Minster Jayalalitha said she is not oppose to samachir kalvi. She opposes the quality is bad. There is nothing wrong with Jayalalitha.
    By
    venkat

  • #4508
    @Venkata kumar,

    How JJ knew the quality of books are bad within a week? Is She went through all pages in a book?

    Priyamudan,
    Suresh Kumar R.
    Engal Vazhvum Engal Valamum Mangaadha Tamizh Endru Sangae Muzhanku

  • #4515
    Basically jj's ideology is not for 'samam'-equality. Eklaiva was pressed to cut his thumb as he outskilled Arjuna . Sambugan was killed by the noble god Rama as he practiced veda. Till now that ideology continues in different forms .It is a continuous struggle to oppress and to raise .Now it is in the form of for and against samachchiir kalvi.It will continue ..let us stand for oppressed


This thread is locked for new responses. Please post your comments and questions as a separate thread.
If required, refer to the URL of this page in your new post.